Page 103 - DCOM504_SECURITY_ANALYSIS_AND_PORTFOLIO_MANAGEMENT
P. 103

Security Analysis and Portfolio Management




                    Notes          where b = dividend payout ratio
                                                            g = (1 – b)(ROE)
                                   where (1 – b) = plough back ratio.
                                   The payout ratio can be calculated using dividend and earnings ratios:

                                                          b = (Dividend/Price)(Price/Earnings)

                                   3.6 Share Buy-back

                                   Buyback is reverse of issue of shares by a company where it offers to take back its shares owned
                                   by the investors at a specified price; this offer can be binding or optional to the investors.






                                     Case Study  Buyback of Shares by MNCs in India

                                        n the financial year 2001-2002, twenty MNCs made buyback offers. Some of the well-
                                        known MNCs  which offered to buy  back their  shares were Philips India Limited
                                     I(Philips), Cadbury India Limited (Cadbury), Britannia Industries Limited (Britannia),
                                     Carrier Aircon (Carrier) and Otis Elevators (Otis). All these companies made open offers
                                     for  the non-promoter  shareholding in  their Indian  subsidiaries. To  buy  back  shares,
                                     Cadbury paid  9 billion, Philips  2 billion, and Carrier, Otis and Reckitt Benkiser all paid
                                     over   1 billion.
                                     According to analysts, the increased buyback activity by MNCs was due to three reasons.
                                     They felt that the share prices of most MNCs were under priced and did not reflect the true
                                     value of the company. Moreover, the buyback of shares allowed MNCs to convert their
                                     Indian ventures into Wholly Owned Subsidiaries (WOS). It also allowed them to delist the
                                     shares of these ventures from the stock markets and thus protect them from the volatility
                                     of the stock markets (caused by scams and other market manipulations).
                                     Analysts also felt that MNCs had used the buyback of shares as a method for distributing
                                     surplus cash to their shareholders. Buyback also acted as a tool for creating wealth for the
                                     shareholders. The buyback of shares improved a company’s return on equity (ROE), and
                                     this improvement would ultimately be reflected in a higher price earning ratio.
                                     Buyback by the company usually indicated that the management felt that the stock was
                                     undervalued. It resulted in an increase in stock price, bringing it closer to the intrinsic
                                     value. For example, when Philips announced its first buyback offer at a maximum price of
                                      105 in October 2000, its shares were trading at around  60. The buyback announcement
                                     resulted in an increase in the share price to  90 even before the buyback offer opened on
                                     November 13, 2000. Hence, the buyback offer gave shareholders an exit option that paid
                                     them a premium over the pre-buyback share price. However, in spite of the benefits of
                                     buyback, a section of analysts and investors felt that it was being misused by MNCs.
                                     Analysts felt that the buyback option may be misused by MNCs to increase their equity
                                     stakes in their  Indian ventures, escape public scrutiny and accountability and  prevent
                                     them  from the  Indian regulatory  environment. Moreover,  the option to convert their
                                     Indian ventures into wholly owned subsidiaries  and delist their shares  from the stock


                                                                                                         Contd...



          98                                LOVELY PROFESSIONAL UNIVERSITY
   98   99   100   101   102   103   104   105   106   107   108