Page 333 - DMGT407Corporate and Business Laws

Corporate and Business Laws

Notes may not order winding up if it finds it to be opposed to public interest or the interest of the
company as a whole.
2. Default in holding statutory meeting: If default is made in delivering the statutory report to
the Registrar or in holding the statutory meeting, the company may be ordered to be wound
up. Petition on this ground can be presented either by the Registrar or by a contributory.
If it has to be filed by any other person, it should be filed before the expiration of 14 days
after the last day on which the statutory meeting ought to have been held [s.439 (7)].

3. Failure to commence business: If a company does not commence business within a year
from incorporation or suspends business for a whole year, it may be ordered to be wound
up. Failure to commence or to carry on business is not treated as a ground for compulsory
winding up unless the company has no intention of carrying on business or it has become
impossible to do so.
4. Reduction in membership: If the number of members is reduced below the statutory
minimum of 7 in a public company or 2 in a private company, the company may be
ordered to be wound up.
5. Inability to pay debts: The Court may order a company to be wound up if it is unable to
pay its debts. According to s.434, a company shall be deemed to be unable to pay its debts
if: (a) a creditor for more than one lakh rupees has served on the company at its registered
office a demand under his hand requiring payment and the company has for three weeks
thereafter neglected to pay or secure or compound the sum to the reasonable satisfaction
of the creditor; or (b) execution or other process issued on a judgement or order of any
court or court in favour of a creditor of the company is returned unsatisfied in whole or in
part; or (c) it is proved to the satisfaction of the court that, the company is unable to pay its
debts, taking into account its contingent and prospective liabilities.

!

Caution Though a contingent and prospective liability is not a debt, the provision that, the
court is to take into account the company’s contingent and prospective liabilities is
important.
A company which has to date paid all its debts as they fell due may still be ordered to be
wound up if a consideration of its assets and liabilities shows that, it will or may shortly
be unable to do so. Inability is to be seen in the commercial sense of a running enterprise
and not in the sense of liquidation, i.e., if the company cannot meet its current demand,
even though its assets, when realised, would exceed its liabilities, it will be deemed to be
unable to pay its debt and may be wound up.

But the important condition to be fulfilled is that, the creditor should have a complete title
to the debt and the debt – a determined or definite sum of money – must have become
payable immediately. Where there is a bona fide dispute regarding the debt, the company
cannot be charged to have neglected to pay it.
The application money due to be refunded to an applicant who applied for shares, but his
application was not accepted, is not a debt. Also, the interest due on such an amount is not
a debt.

Also wages or salary which is due by the company to an employee is not a debt.
The petition on the ground of a company’s inability to pay its debts can be made by a
creditor (including a secured creditor) a debentureholder, and a trustee for debenture
holders. Even a contingent creditor, such as a holder of bill of exchange may make a

326 LOVELY PROFESSIONAL UNIVERSITY