Page 33 - DMGT545_INTERNATIONAL_BUSINESS
P. 33

International Business




                    notes              labour costs because of the prevailing belief in the labour theory of value. However, even
                                       if the assumption of labour cost is discarded and cost differences are translated in terms of
                                       money, the basic contents of the theory will still be valid.
                                   2.   Labor is not the only factor: Another objection against the comparative cost theory is that
                                       it regards labour as the only factor of production. In the modern enterprise, factors like
                                       ‘capital’ and ‘entrepreneur’ assume greater importance as compared to labour. On this
                                       account also, to restrict the cost of production only to labour cost is highly unrealistic and
                                       makes the theory ineffective.
                                   3.   Assumption of constant cost not valid: The classical theory is based on the unrealistic
                                       assumption of constant costs in real life. However, after a certain stage, every production
                                       is subject to increasing costs or diminishing returns. Thus, additional quantities, beyond
                                       this stage, can be produced only at a higher cost. As a result of this, with every increase
                                       in production, the cost-ratios in the two countries may be so altered that they may finally
                                       come to represent equal differences, rather than the comparative differences. The law of
                                       increasing costs, thus, implies another limitation of the theory of comparative cost.
                                   4.   Too  much  emphasis  on  supply  side:  Prof.  Ohlin  criticizes  the  theory  on  account  of  its
                                       complete neglect of the demand conditions. He regards the theory as “nothing more than
                                       abbreviated account of the conditions of supply.” Because of their assumption of constant
                                       costs, classical economist explained the cost difference on the basis of supply conditions
                                       only. But, as we have seen above that costs do not remain constant; they do change with
                                       changes in output, which in turn is influenced by the level of demand.
                                   5.   Static theory: The theory is static in the sense that it assumes so many things as given
                                       and unalterable. Assumptions like ‘full employment’ and ‘fixed and constant supply of
                                       factors of production’ are far from reality. In the real world, everything is changing and
                                       changeable. The theory, therefore, does not fit into the dynamic nature of the present-day
                                       world.
                                   6.   Assumption of perfect mobility of factors within a country and their perfect immobility
                                       between  the  countries  is  not  valid:  Ohlin  regards  this  assumption  as  dangerous  and
                                       misleading. If the factors are mobile within a country, then why are there differences in
                                       wages in different occupations and differences in rates of interest in different regions? He
                                       regards the classical doctrine of comparative costs as a clumsy tool of analysis. Ohlin rejects
                                       the classical assumption of the immobility of factors of production between countries, as
                                       the basis of international trade. For him, immobility of factors is not a special feature of
                                       international trade, but is also prevalent within the different regions of the same country.
                                   7.   Assumption of perfect competition is unrealistic: Like other theories of classical economists,
                                       the comparative cost theory is also based on the assumption of perfect competition but it
                                       has been amply proved by modern economists that perfect competition exists nowhere.
                                       What we actually have is some sort of imperfect competition.
                                   8.   Absence  of  transport  costs:  The  theory  assumes  transport  costs  to  be  absent.  Actually,
                                       however, transport costs do make a difference in the direction and volume of international
                                       trade. There are several branches of production in which transport costs are even higher
                                       than production costs. A particular commodity cannot enter into international trade, unless
                                       the difference in production costs between the two countries is higher than the costs of
                                       transporting it from one country to another. Transport costs are, thus, too important to be
                                       ignored. For example, sometime back Germany was one of the leading exporters of coal
                                       and yet some of the near-by German ports found it more economical to import coal from
                                       Britain. Here, comparative advantage was outweighed by transport costs.
                                   9.   Based on two countries – two commodities model: The theory has also been criticized on the
                                       ground that it takes into consideration only two countries having only two commodities to
                                       exchange. In actual practice, trade is multilateral, involving many countries. This, however,



          28                               lovely Professional university
   28   29   30   31   32   33   34   35   36   37   38