Page 38 - DMGT104_FINANCIAL_ACCOUNTING

Financial Accounting

Notes 5. Cost-Benefit Principle: As per this principle the cost of using an accounting principle
should not exceed its benefits. It does not mean that to curtail the costs, no information or
a little information should be given to the users of the financial statements.
6. Industry Practice: Different accounting principle/practice is adopted in the different
industries. At the time of preparing the financial reports and presenting the accounting
information the prevailing accounting practices in a particular industry should be kept in
mind. For example, disclosing of investments and stock at the cost or market price
whichever is lower. Thus we see that the prevailing accounting practices in an industry
play an important role in adopting the accounting practices.



Caselet Rule versus Principle

tudents of accounting would be well aware of the long discussed differences between
rule-based accounting and principle-based accounting. Both have their protagonists.
SWhile the US GAAP is rule-based, the International Accounting Standards (IAS),
both as IAS and IFRS, are principle-based.

The debate on which is better will be put to rest when the US GAAP converges with IFRS
eventually and becomes principle-based. Being principle-based means that broad principles
are laid out by the standard-fixing body and the interpretation is left to the users of these
standards.
The problem (and also the benefit) with principle-based accounting is that most of the
times, in a situation which requires a finding, one would have to exercise a great deal of
judgment based on substance as opposed to a readymade solution being available for a
particular issue prescribed in the rule-based accounting.
While the US accounting is considered to be rule-based, one can find echoes of principle-
based accounting also in it. In the widely publicised 1969 case of Continental Vending
where the auditors were questioned for lack of professional standards, the court gave a
direction to the jury to look at the facts and the substance of the case rather than rules of
accountancy and mere adherence to GAAP.
The court held that in the audit report the statement “fairly presented … in accordance
with generally accepted accounting principles” is two statements rather than one, i.e.,
“fairly presented” is principle-based and the other “in accordance with generally accepted
accounting principles” is rule-based.
Problems for Auditors
The preparation of financial statements in accordance with the GAAP in a rule-based
environment, however, presents problems to the auditors. If an auditor were to confront
the management over a certain treatment of a transaction, the management is likely to ask
the auditor “show me where it says I can’t do that”.
In other words, in a rule-based environment, the onus is on the auditor to demonstrate
clearly that the particular treatment is not permitted and hence closes the avenues for the
auditor to develop further arguments that would be available in a principle-based
accounting environment (Principles-based Accounting, by Ronald M. Mano, Matthew
Mouritsen and Ryan Pace, published in the CPA Journal, February 2006).
Since accounting standards followed in India have their origin in the IAS, the Indian
accounting standards are principle-based. However, there are exceptions to the rule. One
Contd...

32 LOVELY PROFESSIONAL UNIVERSITY