Page 332 - DCOM504_SECURITY_ANALYSIS_AND_PORTFOLIO_MANAGEMENT
P. 332

Unit 13: Portfolio Performance Evaluation




          13.3 Market Timing                                                                    Notes

          A portfolio manager’s performance has been seen so far in the context of stock selection for
          superior performance. Managers can also generate superior performance from a portfolio by
          planning the investment and disinvestment activities by shifting from stocks to bonds or bonds
          to stocks based on good market timing sense. Positioning of a portfolio is to be adjusted by
          correctly adjusting the direction of the market, either in the bull or bear phases. Managers with
          a forecast of a declining market can position a portfolio either by shifting resources from stocks
          to bonds, or restructure the component stocks in such a way that the beta of the equity portion
          of the portfolio comes down.
          One way of finding the performance of a portfolio in this regard is to simply look directly at the
          way the fund return behaves, relative to the return of the market. This method calls for calculating
          the returns of the portfolio and the market at different intervals and plot a scatter diagram to see
          the direction of relationship between these two. If a portfolio is constructed by concentrating on
          stock selection rather than keeping the market timing in mind, the average beta of the portfolio
          stands fairly constant and if we plot such a portfolio’s returns and market returns, we observe a
          linear relationship. On the other hand, if a manager was able to successfully assess the market
          direction and reshuffle the portfolio accordingly, we would observe a situation of high portfolio
          betas at times of rise in market and low portfolio beta at times of decline in the market.
          Portfolio managers can also achieve superior performance by picking up high beta stocks during
          a market upswing and moving out of equity, one could calculate the quarterly returns for a fund
          and for the market index like Bombay Stock Exchange’s National Index of a 5-year period.

          13.4 Benchmark Portfolios for Performance Evaluation

          Benchmark portfolio is a tool for the meaningful evaluation of the performance of a portfolio
          manager. The more the benchmark reflects the manager’s stated style, the more accurately the
          performance due to a manager’s skills can be assessed. Specialized benchmarks are called “normal
          portfolios.” They are specially constructed by mutual consent of the client and the manager to
          reflect the client’s needs and the manager’s style. Some management firms develop a normal
          portfolio, which they can use for all clients, and some develop it separately for  each type of
          client. When  benchmarks are designed in advance, the portfolio manager  knows what the
          specific objectives are and tailors the portfolio accordingly. The benchmark should reflect the
          appropriate investment universe in which the manager works. Without a yardstick for proper
          comparison, it becomes difficult to distinguish between active management skills and random
          results.
          Rather than using a market index like the  Bombay Stock  Exchange’s Sensitive Index to  the
          Economic Times Index, a benchmark portfolio would use a portfolio with predominantly value-
          oriented shares for a value manager, growth-oriented shares for a growth manager and small
          capitalization shares for a small cap (size) manager. It is quite possible for an investment manager
          to perform  better than the benchmark, though the benchmark may itself under-perform  in
          relation to a market index. The process of constructing a benchmark portfolio involves:
          1.   Defining the universe of stock to be used for the benchmark portfolio, and
          2.   Defining the weightage of the stocks in the universe.

          Performance attribution analysis, as mentioned earlier, is a means of evaluating an investment
          manager’s performance, the return and the sources of return relative to a benchmark portfolio.
          This analysis looks at an investment manager’s total  ‘excess’ return, or ‘active management
          return’ (AMR) relative to its benchmark over the given period.






                                            LOVELY PROFESSIONAL UNIVERSITY                                  327
   327   328   329   330   331   332   333   334   335   336   337